Untradables - Supreme Values

Arctic

Rarity - 4
Description - Covers Knife in a Dark and Light Blue Fog
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Xmas 2022 (Tier 18)

Aurora

Rarity - 4
Description - Covers Knife in a Light Cyan and Pink Aura
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Xmas 2021 (Tier 18)

Bats

Rarity - 9
Description - Surrounds Knife with Bat Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Hallows 2017 Item Pack

Batswarm

Rarity - 4
Description - Gives Knife Black Dust and Bat Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Hallows 2020 (Scary Mode)

Bat Swarm (2024)

Rarity - 2
Description - Gives Knife Black Bat Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Hallows 2024 (25 Kills as Vampire)

Bitsplosion

Rarity - 10
Description - Adds 'Bit' Particles to Knife
Death Effect - Turns Victim into Colorful 'Bits'
Origin - 8-Bit Item Pack

Blizzard

Rarity - 9
Description - Gives You Knife Icicle Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Xmas 2017 Item Pack

Blue Flaming Knife

Rarity - 5
Description - Gives Knife a Blue Flame
Death Effect - Burns Victim With Blue Fire
Origin - In-Game Shop (800 Gems)

Candies

Rarity - 6
Description - Gives Knife Candy Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Hallows 2019 (Tier 8)

Candies 2022

Rarity - 3
Description - Gives Knife Candy Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Hallows 2022 (Tier 8)

Candies (2023)

Rarity - 3
Description - Gives Knife 2023's Candy Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Hallows 2023 (Tier 9)

Candy Cane Effect

Rarity - 8
Description - Gives Knife Candy Cane Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Xmas 2017 (Bought)

Chilly

Rarity - 3
Description - Covers Knife in a White Fog with White Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Xmas 2022 (Tier 7)

Common Ornament

Rarity - 6
Description - Gives Knife White Ornament Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Xmas 2018 (Salvaging a Common)

Cursed

Rarity - 4
Description - Gives Knife a Green Flame-like Aura
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Hallows 2024 (Tier 18)

Darkfire

Rarity - 7
Description - Gives Knife a Black Flame
Death Effect - Burns Victim With Black Fire
Origin - Shadow Item Pack

Darkswirl

Rarity - 4
Description - Gives Knife a Black Swirling Fog
Death Effect - Surrounds Victim With Swirling Fog
Origin - Hallows 2023 Item Pack

Doge

Rarity - 7
Description - Gives Knife Doge Particles
Death Effect - Turns Victim into a Doge
Origin - In-Game Shop (Expired)

Dual Wield

Rarity - 4
Description - Lets the Player
Hold One Knife in Each Hand
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - In-Game Shop (900 Gems)

Easter Glow

Rarity - 4
Description - Gives Knife a Light Blue and Light Purple Glow
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Easter 2023 (Tier 5)

Electric Knife

Rarity - 5
Description - Gives Knife an Electric Effect
Death Effect - Electrocutes Victim
Origin - In-Game Shop (1,000 Gems)

Eliteify

Rarity - 2
Description - Gives Knife Elite Skull Particles
Death Effect - Turns Victim into a Flaming Red Skeleton
Origin - Elite Gamepass

Ethereal

Rarity - 7
Description - Gives Knife a Cyan Fog
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Hallows 2019 Item Pack

Fireworks

Rarity - 3
Description - Gives Knife a Shooting Fireworks Effect with Color Trails
Death Effect - Releases Fireworks on the Victim
Origin - Xmas 2023 (Tier 18)

Flaming Knife

Rarity - 2
Description - Gives Knife an Orange Flame
Death Effect - Burns Victim
Origin - In-Game Shop (4,000 Coins)

Flowers

Rarity - 2
Description - Gives Knife a Beige Aura with White Flower Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Easter 2024 (Tier 6)

Flowerwood

Rarity - 4
Description - Gives Knife a Teal Aura with Teal Revolving Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Easter 2024 Item Pack

Floral

Rarity - 3
Description - Gives Knife a Pink Aura with Blue Flowers
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Summer 2023 (Tier 11)

Flow

Rarity - 4
Description - Gives Knife a Multi-Shade Blue Aura
Death Effect - Surrounds Victim With Water Aura
Origin - Summer 2023 Item Pack

Frostbite

Rarity - 7
Description - Gives Knife a
Frozen Effect
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Xmas 2019 Item Pack

Frostfire

Rarity - 4
Description - Gives Knife a Blue Fog
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Xmas 2020 (Tier 17)

Gearstorm

Rarity - 10
Description - Gives Knife Cog Particles
Death Effect - Turns Victim into a Pile of Cogs
Origin - Steampunk Item Pack

Ghost

Rarity - 1
Description - Gives Knife a White Fog with Ghost Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Hallows 2024 (Tier 1)

Ghostify

Rarity - 2
Description - Makes Knife Translucent with Ghost Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - In-Game Shop (2,000 Coins)

Ghostly

Rarity - 5
Description - Gives Knife an Aqua and Cyan Aura
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Hallows 2022 Item Pack

Ghosts

Rarity - 4
Description - Gives Knife Ghost Particles and a White Fog
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Hallows 2020 (Tier 16)

Ghosts (2023)

Rarity - 1
Description - Gives Knife Ghost Sticker Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Hallows 2023 (Tier 1)

Gingerbread Effect

Rarity - 8
Description - Gives Knife Gingerbread Man Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Xmas 2017 (Bought)

Glisten

Rarity - 4
Description - Gives Knife Radiating Beams of Blue and Purple Light
Death Effect - Radiates Victim with Beams of Blue and Purple Light
Origin - Summer 2024 Item Pack

Glowy

Rarity - 3
Description - Gives Knife a Neon Fog with Color-Changing Pumpkin Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Hallows 2023 (Tier 17)

Green Flaming Knife

Rarity - 5
Description - Gives Knife a Green Flame
Death Effect - Burns Victim With Green Fire
Origin - In-Game Shop (800 Gems)

Hallow's Blaze

Rarity - 4
Description - Gives Knife an Orange Mist
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Hallows 2020 (Scary Mode)

Heartify

Rarity - 2
Description - Gives Knife Heart Particles
Death Effect - Gives Victim Heart Eyes
Origin - In-Game Shop (2,400 Cns.)

Ice Magic

Rarity - 6
Description - Covers Knife in a Cyan and Pink Aura
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Xmas 2021 Item Pack

Jellyfish

Rarity - 3
Description - Gives Knife Multi-Colored Jellyfish Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Summer 2024 (Tier 8)

Jingle

Rarity - 5
Description - Gives Knife a Green and Red Bright Effect
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Xmas 2020 (Tier 13)

Knifeception

Rarity - 4
Description - Surrounds Knife in
a Particle of Your Equipped Knife
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - In-Game Shop (300 Gems)

Knife Wrapper

Rarity - 8
Description - Wraps Knife in Green Christmas Wrapping
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Xmas 2017 (Bought)

Legendary Ornament

Rarity - 7
Description - Gives Knife a Red Ornament Particle
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Xmas 2018 (Salvaging a Legendary)

Matrix

Rarity - 3
Description - Gives Knife a Green Glitchy Aura
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Easter 2024 (10 Rare Eggs)

Minty

Rarity - 3
Description - Surrounds Knife in Small Red and White Bursts
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Xmas 2022 (Tier 14)

Monify

Rarity - 10
Description - Does Not Change Knife's Appearance
Death Effect - Turns Victim into Money
Origin - In-Game Shop (Expired)

Musical

Rarity - 2
Description - Makes a Musical Sound after killing
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - In-Game Shop (2,000 Coins)

Northern Lights

Rarity - 7
Description - Gives Knife an Aurora Effect
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Xmas 2018 (Bought)

Petals

Rarity - 5
Description - Gives Knife a Pink Aura with Pink Petal Particles
Death Effect - Petals Fall from the Victim
Origin - Valentine's 2023 Item Pack

Phantom

Rarity - 4
Description - Gives Knife a Yellowish-Green Flame Effect
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Hallows 2021 (Tier 22)

Pink Flaming Knife

Rarity - 5
Description - Gives Knife a Pink Flame
Death Effect - Burns Victim With Pink Fire
Origin - In-Game Shop (800 Gems)

Plasma

Rarity - 5
Description - Gives Knife a Blue and Purple Aura
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Plasma Bundle

Poison

Rarity - 6
Description - Gives Knife a
Green Dripping Effect
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Hallows 2019 (Tier 18)

Pumpkin

Rarity - 7
Description - Surrounds Knife with Pumpkin Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Hallows 2017 (Bought)

Pumpkin 2022

Rarity - 3
Description - Gives Knife Pumpkin Face Particles and an Orange Aura
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Hallows 2022 (Tier 12)

Radioactive

Rarity - 2
Description - Gives Knife Hazard Sign Particles
Death Effect - Turns Victim Green
Origin - In-Game Shop (1,600 Coins)

Rainbow

Rarity - 5
Description - Gives Knife a Rainbow-Colored Aura
Death Effect - Surrounds Victim with Rainbow-Colored Aura
Origin - Easter 2023 Item Pack

Rainbow Flaming Knife

Rarity - 10
Description - Gives Kmife a Rainbow Flame
Death Effect - Burns Victim With Chroma Fire
Origin - MM2 Shop Promo

Rare Ornament

Rarity - 7
Description - Gives Knife a Green Ornament Effect
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Xmas 2018 (Salvaging a Rare)

Snowfall

Rarity - 4
Description - Gives Knife a Snow Falling Effect
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Xmas 2020 (Tier 7)

Snowflake

Rarity - 1
Description - Covers Knife in Snowflakes
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Xmas 2021 (Tier 1)

Snowflakes

Rarity - 8
Description - Covers Knife in Snowflakes
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Xmas 2016 (Bought)

Snowflakes 2017

Rarity - 7
Description - Gives Knife Snowflake Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Xmas 2017 (Bought)

Starry

Rarity - 4
Description - Covers Knife in Stars
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Xmas 2021 (Tier 16)

Stars

Rarity - 3
Description - Gives Knife Star Particles with a Golden Aura
Death Effect - Emits Stars from the Victim
Origin - Xmas 2023 (Tier 14)

Stickers

Rarity - 1
Description - Surrounds Knife in Ornaments and Peppermints
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Xmas 2022 (Tier 1)

Sunbeams

Rarity - 2
Description - Gives Knife Beams of Yellow Light Radiating Off of It
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Summer 2024 (Tier 5)

Swirls

Rarity - 2
Description - Gives Knife Candy Swirl Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Xmas 2023 (Tier 7)

Toxic

Rarity - 3
Description - Gives Knife Green Bubble Particles and a Green Aura
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Hallows 2022 (Tier 16)

Traveler's Flame

Rarity - 3
Description - Gives Knife an Orange Flaming Aura
Death Effect - Surrounds Victim With Orange Flaming Aura
Origin - Hallows 2023 (Tier 27)

Uncommon Ornament

Rarity - 6
Description - Gives Knife Blue Ornament Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Xmas 2018 (Salvaging an Uncommon)

Vampire

Rarity - 6
Description - Gives Knife Red Smoke and Blood Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Hallows 2020 Item Pack

Vampiric

Rarity - 3
Description - Gives Knife Red Smoky Aura
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Hallows 2024 (Tier 14)

Versus

Rarity - 1
Description - Gives Knife Survior and Zombie Logo Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Hallows 2022 (Tier 1)

Void

Rarity - 3
Description - Surrounds Knife in Light Purple Fog and Particles
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Prime Gaming Promo

Wraith

Rarity - 4
Description - Gives Knife Black and White Smoky Aura
Death Effect - Emits the Black and White Smoke from the Victim
Origin - Hallows 2024 Item Pack

Wraithfire

Rarity - 4
Description - Gives Knife a
Purple Flame Effect
Death Effect - N/A
Origin - Hallows 2021 (Tier 28)

Default Radio

Rarity - 0
Origin - Given Upon Buying the Radio Gamepass
Obtained - Buy the Radio Gamepass

Blue Candy Cane

Rarity - 8
Origin - Xmas 2017 (Bought)

Blue Candy Cane '18

Rarity - 7
Origin - Xmas 2018 (Bought)

Blue Sparkletime

Rarity - 7
Origin - In-Game Shop (1,000 Gems)

Bluesteel

Rarity - 3
Origin - In-Game Shop (3,200 Coins)

Boombastic

Rarity - 3
Origin - In-Game Shop (3,600 Coins)

Camo

Rarity - 3
Origin - In-Game Shop (2,000 Coins)

Candy

Rarity - 6
Origin - Hallows 2019 (Tier 13)

Candy Cane

Rarity - 8
Origin - Xmas 2016 (Bought)

Candy Cane '18

Rarity - 6
Origin - Xmas 2018 (Bought)

Coal

Rarity - 6
Origin - Xmas 2017 (Bought)

Diamond

Rarity - 8
Origin - In-Game Shop (2,500 Gems)

Dubstep

Rarity - 2
Origin - In-Game Shop (1,200 Coins)

Elderwood

Rarity - 8
Origin - Hallows 2019 (Bought)

Elite

Rarity - 2
Origin - Elite Gamepass

Fade

Rarity - 4
Origin - In-Game Shop (400 Gems)

Flaming

Rarity - 6
Origin - In-Game Shop (900 Gems)

Ghost

Rarity - 5
Origin - Hallows 2020 (Tier 20)

Gingerbread

Rarity - 9
Origin - Xmas 2016 (Bought)

Golden

Rarity - 6
Origin - In-Game Shop (12,000 Coins)

Green Candy Cane

Rarity - 8
Origin - Xmas 2017 (Bought)

Green Sparkletime

Rarity - 7
Origin - In-Game Shop (1,000 Gems)

Hallowradio

Rarity - 5
Origin - Hallows 2020 (Scary Mode)

Ice

Rarity - 7
Origin - Xmas 2017 (Bought)

Iceplayer

Rarity - 7
Origin - Xmas 2020 (Bought)

Jack-o-Radio

Rarity - 7
Origin - Hallows 2019 (Tier 21)

Minty

Rarity - 8
Origin - Xmas 2019 (Bought)

Omega

Rarity - 4
Origin - In-Game Shop (400 Gems)

Overseer

Rarity - 9
Origin - In-Game Shop

Pink Sparkletime

Rarity - 7
Origin - In-Game Shop (1,000 Gems)

Rainbow

Rarity - 6
Origin - In-Game Shop (800 Gems)

Reaver

Rarity - 6
Origin - Hallows 2021 (Bought)

Red Sparkletime

Rarity - 7
Origin - In-Game Shop (1,000 Gems)

Snowy

Rarity - 10
Origin - Xmas 2016 (Bought)

Swirly Radio

Rarity - 6
Origin - Xmas 2021 (Bought)

Tree

Rarity - 8
Origin - Xmas 2018 (Bought)

Vampire

Rarity - 3
Origin - Hallows 2024 (Tier 16)

Beach Ball

Rarity - 3
Ability - Holds a Beach Ball when equipped.
Origin - Summer 2023 (Tier 5)

BooSign

Rarity - 4
Ability - Puts up a "BOO" sign when equipped.
Origin - Hallows 2021 (Tier 4)

Bunny Toy

Rarity - 2
Ability - Equips a Bunny toy.
Origin - Easter 2024 (Tier 4)

Candle

Rarity - 4
Ability - Puts a candle on the ground when clicked.
Origin - Hallows 2024 (100 Kills as Vampire)

Candy Emote

Rarity - 3
Ability - Takes out a piece of candy that changes colors each time it's equipped. Has a chance of being on fire when equipped.
Origin - Hallows 2022 (Tier 5)

Chocolate Milk

Rarity - 2
Ability - Takes out a cup of chocolate milk when equipped.
Origin - In-Game Shop
Obtained - Buying from the In-Game Shop

Coconut

Rarity - 2
Ability - Takes out a Sippable Tropical Coconut Drink.
Origin - Summer 2024 (Tier 3)

Cookie

Rarity - 1
Ability - Takes out an edible cookie.
Origin - Xmas 2023 (Tier 1)

Dab

Rarity - 5
Ability - Makes you dab when equipped.
Origin - In-Game Shop (2,800 Coins)

Egg Toy

Rarity - 5
Ability - Takes out a randomized Easter 2023 egg.
Origin - Easter 2023 Bingo

Egg Toy (2024)

Rarity - 2
Ability - Equips a normal Egg from the Easter 2024 event.
Origin - Easter 2024 (Tier 2)

Floss

Rarity - 6
Ability - Makes you floss when equipped.
Origin - In-Game Shop (750 Gems)

Firefly Jar

Rarity - 3
Ability - Releases fireflies from the jar when you left click.
Origin - In-Game Shop (1,500 Coins)

GG Sign

Rarity - 3
Ability - Puts up a "GG" sign when equipped.
Origin - In-Game Shop (100 Gems)

Gravestone

Rarity - 2
Ability - Puts a gravestone on the ground when clicked.
Origin - Hallows 2024 (Tier 5)

Headless

Rarity - 10
Ability - Takes your avatars head off then puts it back on when equipped.
Origin - Hallows 2018 (Tier 25)

Ice Cream

Rarity - 2
Ability - Takes out an ice cream cone when equipped.
Origin - In-Game Shop (400 Coins)

Key Toy

Rarity - 5
Ability - Takes out a colored key that changes colors each time it's equipped.
Origin - Hallows 2020 (Scary Mode)

Ninja Rest

Rarity - 4
Ability - Your avatar will stand
on one arm when equipped.
Origin - In-Game Shop (2,600 Coins)

Pie

Rarity - 2
Ability - Takes out a slice of pumpkin pie.
Origin - Thanksgiving 2023 (Tier 2)

Prank Bomb

Rarity - 4
Ability - When used (left click), it will place a bomb that explodes with confetti after a few seconds.
Origin - In-Game Shop (4,800 Coins)

Pizza

Rarity - 2
Ability - Takes out a slice of pizza when equipped.
Origin - In-Game Shop (400 Coins)

Pumpkin Toy

Rarity - 3
Ability - Takes out a placeable, carvable pumpkin when equipped. To carve, press left-click.
Origin - Hallows 2023 (Tier 23)

Sand Bucket

Rarity - 2
Ability - Takes out a Sand Bucket (it may be able to place down sand castles).
Origin - Summer 2024 (Tier 6)

Sit

Rarity - 2
Ability - Makes your avatar sit when equipped.
Origin - In-Game Shop (800 Coins)

Snowball

Rarity - 5
Ability - Takes out a throwable snowball, right click to throw.
Origin - Xmas 2020 (Tier 9)

Spellbook

Rarity - 3
Ability - Opens the spellbook and releases a random effect when clicked.
Origin - Hallows 2024 (Tier 12)

Spray Paint

Rarity - 6
Ability - Takes out a bottle of spray paint. You can input IDs for decals that you want to spray.
Origin - In-Game Shop (750 Gems)

Rare Egg Toy

Rarity - 2
Ability - Equips a Rare Egg from the Easter 2024 event.
Origin - Easter 2024 (2 Rare Eggs)

Reaver Sign

Rarity - 4
Ability - Puts up a sign with the Reaver on it when equipped.
Origin - Hallows 2021 (Tier 25)

Survivor Sign

Rarity - 4
Ability - Puts up a sign with the Survivor logo on it when equipped.
Origin - Hallows 2022 (Tier 9 | Survivor)

Teddy Bear

Rarity - 2
Ability - Takes out a toy teddy bear that you can left click to
hug.
Origin - In-Game Shop (600 Coins)

Toy Candy

Rarity - 6
Ability - Takes out a piece of candy that changes colors each time it's equipped. Has a chance of being on fire when equipped.
Origin - Hallows 2019 (Tier 27)

Toy Candy 2

Rarity - 4
Ability - Takes out a piece of candy that changes colors each time it's equipped. Has a chance of being on fire when equipped.
Origin - Hallows 2020 (Tier 14)

Toy Candy 3

Rarity - 4
Ability - Takes out a piece of candy that changes colors each time it's equipped. Has a chance of being on fire when equipped.
Origin - Hallows 2021 (Tier 10)

Toy Token

Rarity - 6
Ability - Takes out a snow token that changes colors each time
it's equipped.
Origin - Xmas 2019 (Tier 22)

Treat Bucket

Rarity - 6
Ability - Left clicking puts the bucket against your mouth and makes the "nom nom nom" sound.
Origin - Hallows 2019 (Tier 16)

Villager's Lantern

Rarity - 2
Ability - Takes out a lantern with a green flame.
Origin - Hallows 2024 (5 Kills as Vampire)

Water Balloon

Rarity - 3
Ability - Takes out a Throwable Water Balloon.
Origin - Summer 2024 (Tier 9)

Zen

Rarity - 5
Ability - When equipped, it makes your avatar meditate
while bobbing up and down.
Origin - In-Game Shop (800 Gems)

Zombie

Rarity - 10
Ability - Makes your avatar's arms stick out and your head bob side to side.
Origin - Hallows 2018 (Tier 16)

Zombie Friend

Rarity - 6
Ability - Upon left clicking, the zombie turns around and faces you or looks at the back of your head. It also makes a roar sound.
Origin - Hallows 2019 (Tier 12)

Zombie Sign

Rarity - 4
Ability - Puts up a sign with the Zombie logo on it when equipped.
Origin - Hallows 2022 (Tier 9 | Zombie)

Fake Gun

Ability - Makes your knife look like a gun temporarily.
Price - 400 Gems/3,000 Coins

Footsteps

Ability - Lets you see the footstep history of innocents.
Price - Given upon joining for the first time

Ghost

Ability - Go invisible for a few seconds.
Price - 800 Gems/6,000 Coins

Haste

Ability - You move 10% faster while holding your knife out. This enables you to outrun innocents.
Price - 400 Gems/3,000 Coins

Ninja

Ability - Your knife becomes silent when killing someone.
Price - 100 Gems/1,000 Coins

Sleight

Ability - Lets you throw knives quicker.
Price - 100 Gems/1,000 Coins

Sprint

Ability - Activate to temporarily gain a 50% speed boost.
Price - 400 Gems/3,000 Coins

Trap

Ability - Places an invisible trap that stops innocents. Maximum of three placed per round.
Price - 400 Gems/3,000 Coins

X-Ray

Ability - See through walls for a few seconds with a thirty second cooldown.
Price - 800 Gems/6,000 Coins